What might the incident involving Asher asking for a smack instead of a snack indicate about the community?

What might the incident involving Asher asking for a smack instead of a snack indicate about the community?

In this community, however, when Asher makes a childlike mistake in language, he gets what he asked for – a smack. However, in that society, precision of language is important for maintaining the peacefulness of their existence.

When Asher was three what would happen when he said smack instead of snack?

The community uses something called a Discipline Wand to smack children as a reprimand for misbehavior. As a three year old, little Asher really wanted his snack, but said “smack” instead. At this point, “Asher whimpered, cringed, and corrected himself instantly” in a whisper.

What happened to Asher when 3 was smacked a lot?

Q. Why did Asher get smacked a lot when he was a three? He kept stealing apples from the Recreation Area. He kept saying “smack” instead of “snack.”

What happened to Asher when he was a three because he had difficulty with precision of language?

Asher’s poor vocabulary sometimes gets him into trouble, such as when he was three and used the word “smack” instead of “snack.” He was repeatedly punished for his mistake until, for a period, he didn’t speak at all. These incidents epitomize the rigid control the authorities exercise over the community.

What was Fiona’s assignment in the giver?

In Lowry’s original story, Fiona is assigned to be a Caretaker of the Old. That means the young Twelve is tasked with caring for the elderly of her society, with bathing them and helping make them as comfortable as possible just before they are euthanized, or “released.”

What assignment did Asher get?

Assistant Director of Recreation
His friend Asher is assigned the position of Assistant Director of Recreation after the Chief Elder gives a long and humorous speech about Asher’s pleasant, fun-loving nature and the trouble he has had in using precise language.

What was Asher’s punishment for saying smack?

Having used imprecise language, Asher must suffer the consequences. He asked for a smack, and now he’s going to get one. A childcare worker duly administers his punishment, whacking him across his hands with a discipline wand. A whimpering, cringing Asher promptly corrects himself.

Who said I want my smack in the giver?

As a Three, eager for his juice and crackers at snacktime, he one day said “smack” instead of “snack” as he stood waiting in line for the morning treat. Jonas remembered it clearly. He could still see little Asher, wiggling with impatience in the line. He remembered the cheerful voice call out, “I want my smack!”

What happens when Jonas ask Asher to ride home with him after the ceremony?

What happens when Jonas asks Asher to ride home with him after the Ceremony? Asher hesitates. Asher says he doesn’t want to be friends anymore. Which of the following is a rule for the Receiver of Memory?

What was the negative effect on Asher?

Asher was given the prescribed punishment for his error, but as weeks went by, he kept making the same mistake. His punishment escalated to a “series of painful lashes that left marks on (his) legs”, and for a time Asher, traumatized, “stopped talking altogether”.

How does Asher apologize?

“I apologize for inconveniencing my learning community.” Asher ran through the standard apology phrase rapidly, still caching his breath. The Instructor and class waited patiently for his explanation. The students had all been grinning, because they had listened to Asher’s explanations so many times before.

What is Asher’s biggest flaw?

While Asher never trespasses enough to warrant release, his inability to fit neatly into the community’s rules nevertheless vexes the elders. Even when Asher receives his assignment, a moment meant to celebrate his achievements, the Chief Elder tells a humiliating story of a teacher hitting Asher.

Why was Asher punished in the Giver book?

In The Giver, Asher was punished as a child for confusing the words “snack” and “smack” because the community values precise language. Citizens are required to use precise language at all times, and even exaggerations are prohibited.

Why did Asher mix up the words snack and Smack?

When Asher and Jonas were Threes, Asher mixed up the words “snack” and “smack” one day as he was standing in line for his morning snack. The Childcare worker immediately gave him what he said he wanted: a smack.

Why did Asher stop talking as a toddler?

As a toddler, Asher “always talked too fast and mixed up words” while he was trying to master precision of language (ch 7, p. 55). The community’s obsession with precision led to poor Asher being punished over and over again for saying the wrong word, to the point that he stopped talking altogether.

Why was Jonas scolded in the giver?

In another scene, we learn that Jonas was scolded for using the word “starving,” when he really just meant “hungry.” The community does not want its citizens to ever think they could starve; they are self-sufficient and so thoroughly organized that starvation has become an impossibility.